The Worst Tax Preparer Reviews

Client Review of

Raymond L. Portela

Granada Hills, CA

Van Nuys, CA
October 21, 2020

Raymond L. Portela (PTIN LAST 4: 1833) was the tax preparer for my 2019 taxes. On my tax return I was given $603 this was Raymond calculations. I was then told by him I owed $7 to the Sate of CA. I paid the $7 on July 5th, before my due which I believe was between July 7th-10th. I received a letter 9/16/2020 from the State of CA Franchise Tax Board stating I owed $65.56. Raymond calculation was $603, & their was $538. I contacted Raymond IMMEDIATELY about the notice he says he will get in contact with them and figure things out. September 30th I contacted him again since I got not update for 14days, their was no response from Raymond. October 3rd, I contacted Raymond stating “ Have you figure out what was the problem with my 2019 taxes”... He responded “ Hi Monesh Still working on it Trying to reach someone at FTB To figure out what changed in their side“ I told him “ok thank you”. On October 11th I contacted him again stating “ Has their been any fixing for my taxes?“, he read my message but not response. On October 21st which is today I am writing this review I contacted him stating “ Hello it been about a month since I text you about my taxes and you still haven’t got in contact with me! What going on, it say that I owe money but I have paid the $7 you said I owe, I sent you the receipt of the payment. Now the paper work is say I owe $65 that was due on Oct 1st. Now I’m sure I owe more because the payment hasn’t been paid! Either you made a mistake on my taxes or the state did. It would be very professional and considerate if you get in contact with me ASAP!” And STILL NO RESPONSE FROM HIM! BEWARE OF RAYMOND L. PORTELA! I still have all the messages saved and will be pursing a small claim against him in FRAUD OF TAXES
Client Review of

Sean M. Johnson, CPA

Tampa, FL

Tampa, FL
October 19, 2020

My accountant died this past year from complications of pancreatic cancer. His business was purchased by Broyles, Rooks, and Johnson CPAs. I figured that the easiest way to have my taxes done was to go with the new firm for continuity. I filed an extension filed this year, so my tax return would be due October 15, 2020. I dropped off my documents with Broyles, Rooks, and Johnson on September 14, 2020. They didn’t contact me for a couple weeks, so I started calling to get updates starting October 1, 2020 just to make sure that all was going as planned. I made five calls between October 1 and October 16. The first three calls, I left messages with the receptionists (Jordan and Michelle). They couldn’t give information about my return because, “they aren’t the CPAs” and no CPAs were available and my phone calls were unreturned. The fourth call was a week before the filing deadline, and Jordan (receptionist) spoke with the CPA and assured me that my tax return would be prepared and filed on time. October 15, 2020 came and went. I called October 16, 2020 and spoke to Jordan again. She said all CPAs were out of the office and she could not tell me if return was completed or filed. She said to call on Monday, October 19, 2020 for more information. On Monday, Michelle and someone new, a Ms. Spence, advised me that my tax return was not done, and they couldn’t tell me when they would be done because they have a lot of returns still to do. The deadline for tax submission had obviously passed already with them having my documents for a month. They suggested that I should take comfort in the fact that I was one of many clients for whom they did not file returns on time (can’t make this stuff up). I collected my documents from them and have now found another accountant. In summary, if you would like a CPA that does not answer the phone, return calls, or meet important deadlines, this is the firm for you. If you would like your taxes submitted on time or have any interest in communication with your CPA, I’d look elsewhere.
Client Review of

Harvey Altman, CPA

Jericho, NY

Palo Alto, CA
October 15, 2020

As a small business owner, what you need is to have someone you can trust your taxes! Right? I rarely write (bad) reviews online. Being a business owner myself, I know how bad reviews can harm your business. That being said, I do feel obligated to share my experience with Harvey Altman CPA. We have now used Harvey Altman CPA for four years. Prior we had Deloitte for 14 years. As an SMB (LLC), we have a relatively straight forward noncomplex situation. "You "hire them on a retainer and a fixed price". That is all looks good, you might think! However, we have experienced an increase in unforeseen and "unexpected" bills from them over the years - usually just a few days before Tax Day. They bill you for services they have not done. When you flag it and ask them about the billing details, they will respond aggressively and say things like", please understand that accounting is a service industry", etc. Their politics is they do not file your taxes before you paid bills due despite they "make" up bills last minute, you have never accepted or agreed upon. I cannot recommend this company at all. We have flagged this to our legal team. If you want to avoid this ...do not hire The Team Harvey Altman as your CPAs. You might ask, " how bad can it be?" Well, we had an annual retainer of $1.200 / $2.500. However, this year they billed us, with no warning, no further - $11.300. We have now filed a complaint to Board of Accountancy, as well as flagged them in the community.
Client Review of

Eduardo A. Tovar, CPA

Austin, TX

Austin, TX
October 15, 2020

I honestly don't know where to begin, so let's just jump in w/ DO NOT deal w/ Premier Tax Service. I am going to tell you about last year's experience, then I will tell you about this year's experience. You're probably asking why did I go back the second year if the first was so bad, well b/c I'm an idiot. Side Note: I was recommended PTS by an ADP representative trying to sell me payroll, which by the way, Eddie will try non-stop to get you to sign a deal w/ them b/c he gets a kickback. If you're on the fence about it, he will literally have an ADP rep come into the office while you're there and go over the paperwork w/ you and push for you to sign. Just remember this if you don't have payroll and decide to see Eddie anyways. As soon as you hear ADP and how much you need it, you'll realize this post is an honest indication of how the rest of your experience is going to be. Last year: I called PTS to set up an appointment, which was done successfully, but like most people, I imagine, I asked what I needed to bring in and what kinds of things I should be thinking about, like categories for expenditures or education considerations or various credits etc. I was told that they would email me a list of expense categories and bring anything else I think may be needed. I never received the email. I show up for my appointment, Eddie looks everything over, says I'm missing a few things for what I'm claiming (hence I asked what I needed to bring in), but then prepares my taxes and has me sign. He then processes my payment to PTS, over $600 for a personal return and business return, and reminds me that I need to send him over the missing items. He then explains how I can pay the IRS the taxes owed. No problem right? Wrong. I send him over the items and don't hear anything for a week. So I call the office and am told someone will call me back, never did. I write an email, never receive a response. It got to the point that I had to call, and write an email, every 30 minutes begging them to complete my taxes so I can pay what's owed. This took OVER TWO MONTHS for them to file my taxes and the email afterwards, which was received on April 11, 2019, literally said, "Everything has been handled. You can make the IRS payment at any time now. Best if you pay by April 15th to avoid penalties and interest." In short, PTS is comparable to a bad waiter. Doesn't really care about their service and as soon as you pay the bill, don't expect anything more, even if you haven't received everything you ordered. This year: I call PTS to set up an appointment and they tell me, "just send in the documents, you don't need to come in." Sure, maybe some would prefer this option, but when I deal w/ my money, I want to handle it in-person if possible so I can ask questions should any pop up. After a five-minute back and forth, they tell me they have to go talk to Eddie to see when he is taking appointments. I can't say for sure whether or not he helicopter parents his staff, but in all of the interactions I've had with them, I can't blame him for doing so either. Interesting fact, I didn't see one familiar face in his office this year, well except for his own. So I go in, we do the preliminary dance, I leave w/ my to do list. Coronavirus happens, life gets shuffled, and I end up reaching out again end of March/beginning of April. I have to leave town for work and am told not to worry, they will file the extension for me. Sounds good, thank you. WELL, one thing I was not aware of, that would have been nice to know, is that extensions only adjust the timeframe in which to file, not deadline before which taxes owed should be paid. So what happens is I go to see Eddie when I get back and sure enough, I have fines and fees added to my return that I need to pay. The frustrating part is that I made relatively the same amount as I did the prior year, so we had a good guesstimate of what I would owe. I could have just made a payment to the IRS before April 15th an